01189998819991197253

Is it actually beneficial to be good at problem solving? At first this question might seem nonsensical. Of course it’s beneficial. Life constantly throws problems at us that threaten our wellbeing, our mood, our strategic position and sometimes even our lives. To address these problems was the entire reason we evolved such a sophisticated brain. And even beyond our personal lives, our problem solving ability is probably the most important factor for making us valuable as a member of a workforce. If you can solve problems that only very few other people can solve, you can earn a lot of money.

The reason I’m asking the question, though, is that you can’t solve all the problems. The game of whack-a-mole you’re playing with all the problems life throws at you will not end unless a problem you can’t solve will cost you your life. You cannot win. And it’s not like there’s going to be a high-score at the end, nobody will care about how many problems you solved because nobody but you can know how many you had. And sure, if you solve a very big problem that lots of people besides you had, you might get some recognition for that, but you have to be quite lucky to find one of these problems that you can actually solve. And what is that recognition worth if the stream of problems simply doesn’t stop.

Arguably, some problems are bigger than others. The bigger the problems you have, the more likely it is to run into the one that ends it all. So anyone tries to solve those problems. The image of running around with a fire extinguisher comes to mind, constantly putting out fires all around you. But what if you had a really good fire extinguisher that puts the fires out faster? It does not prevent new fires from popping up everywhere, it does not prevent you from running frantically to the latest one, it just saves a bit of time extinguishing. That’s still good, right? You spend a lot less time extinguishing fires, right?

Wrong. Because it turns out those fires usually don’t just pop up out of nowhere after all. They are caused by even more, even bigger fires all around you and they are roaring infernos that your little fire extinguisher can barely make a dent. So what are you going to do? If you have a fire extinguisher in your hands, you kind of have the obligation to use it if there is a fire. But you can’t extinguish all those big fires, you probably can’t even extinguish one. So how do you choose which one to fight and how do you justify that you’re not doing anything about the others? How do you justify that you’re also not solving the ones you’re trying to solve. How do you justify ever taking a break with so many fires around?

You wouldn’t have to justify yourself that much if you had fires constantly threatening you. You wouldn’t have to justify yourself that much if your extinguisher was puny and you’d take so long extinguishing one fire that another one pops up in the meantime. You’d have everyone’s sympathy and maybe some people would even help you put out a fire or two. Despite everything, humans are social creatures and cooperation is what defines us. You might think the downside is that you’d be quite unhappy about having to put out all those fires, but that’s just because you don’t know that it never stops. Everyone is unhappy about that all the time.

So why should you become good at problem solving then? Why should you improve your fire extinguisher? Well, because it’s fun. Solving problems, no matter what type, is satisfying. Our brains are built to make it that way. You don’t necessarily have a better life if you’re good at problem solving, but at least you get to solve a lot of problems. Don’t look at how badly the problem affects you, don’t imagine how good your life could be without it and don’t ever think it might be the last one. It never is, there will always be more and they’ll only get more difficult. Just look at the only part of the process that you can reliably say is worth it: the satisfaction of solving problems. Because if that’s your attitude, you might even feel a little delightful anticipation the next time something catches fire.

Oh, and please don’t take that last sentence out of context.

Comic transcript

Panel 1:
Chicken and Big Cockatoo are sitting in the prison's canteen.
H: I have news. My lawyer just informed me that new evidence surfaced and apparently I will be released. I’m happy about it but unfortunately it also means that I’ll be leaving.
C: Wha ... ?!
Panel 2:
C: But ... who’s going to do math with me then? That’s not fair. The good people always leave so soon while only the bad people stay ...
H: Yeah, that’s kind of the point of a prison, though. And you’re not a bad person.
C: Well no, but ... hang on ...
Panel 3:
C: ... You’re right! I’ve never done anything wrong! I don’t need to be in prison! I’m coming with you!
H: Whoa, you sure? You’ve never been outside.
C: But I’ll be with a friend! You’ll look after me, will you?
H: Of course!